My prophecy posts have ended with more of a whimper than a bang, but the final curtain is lowering...
I ended my last post with the declaration that the specialness of the Old Testament prophets as specific individuals chosen to be the messengers of God has ended with the fulfillment of Joel 2 as quoted in Acts 2 at Pentecost with the pouring out of the Spirit on all flesh that all may prophesy. This is seen also in 1 Corinthians 14:1,5
Pursue love, and earnestly desire the spiritual gifts, especially that you may prophesy... Now I want you all to speak in tongues, but even more to prophesy.
All can prophesy, yet more than that, all should desire to prophesy. That doesn't mean all do, but prophesy is now in the domain of all.
However, that's not the entire story. Earlier on I highlighted the presence of New Testament prophets upon which the foundation of the church was laid. While all can prophesy with the arrival of the Spirit of God on all those who trust in Christ as Lord, the Old Testament line of prophets concluded not with John (though they did in one sense) but more so with the revelation of the mystery of Christ and the gospel to the Gentiles.
There is a difference between big 'P' Prophets and little 'p' prophets. Most people say that difference is Old Testament versus New Testament. I think the Biblical view is a tad more nuanced than that. The Prophets ends not with the arrival of Jesus but with the apostles and prophets who took the gospel to the Gentiles. While I'm not sure at what point the last prophet in this line died out, in my mind there is a definitive break here. Problems arise when we confuse where exactly we come into the picture. We see the similarity we have with the apostles with all prophesying in Acts 2. We could perhaps then conclude therefore our words can have the same weight and influence and divine inspiration as the apostles. It is essential we notice the cross-over (represented below in grey) between prophecy of the Old Testament few and the New Testament many. Without acknowledging the period of crossover we will unfortunately either want to add to the Bible new chapters, or else minimise the role of the Bible and overemphasise the words of Christians today.

So what do we make of the gift of prophecy continuing from Ephesians 4:11? At this point I would contend the gift of prophecy needs to be thought of like we speak of the gift of evangelism. All can do it, all should desire to, but not all will. Some will be especially good at it. These will be spoken of as having the gift of prophecy. While all can prophesy, some Prophets will be especially gifted;
This leaves us with a just the elephant in the room to address. What is prophecy? Without wishing to oversimplify. To boil it down to it's essence; prophecy is the testimony of Jesus as Lord. Actually, that does oversimplify it, but it is also the core of it's content. See Revelation 19:10;
the testimony of Jesus is the spirit of prophecy.
Or again in 1 John 4:1-3
Beloved, do not believe every spirit, but test the spirits to see whether they are from God, for many false prophets have gone out into the world. By this you know the Spirit of God: every spirit that confesses that Jesus Christ has come in the flesh is from God, and every spirit that does not confess Jesus is not from God.
One of the observations coming out of MYC was that we came with lots of questions about the Holy Spirit and his work. We got the answers and they just weren't exciting enough. How could a topic as exciting as spiritual warfare be so bland to suggest the war is pretty much over? It's really just the last few pieces being played out in chess where the result is already decided. But I wanted to fight! It sounds so simple. We all can prophesy as we speak the message of Christ as Lord.
Are you dissatisfied with the answer? Why can't we write Scripture? We don't need to. The canon is closed, the foundation laid and the Spirit of God is in our hearts helping us to understand the truth as we meditate on God's word. We can all prophesy as we speak the message of Christ as Lord.
There it is. My elective which took 1.5 hours to run has only taken me two weeks to blog! For those with the inclination, please highlight for me the mistakes in my logic. As iron sharpens iron...
I have one more question to address in my mind, but unfortunately I've run out of time and energy again. Later this week I will offer just one more post reflecting some unfinished thoughts on "so just what is the difference between teaching, prophecy and evangelism?"