Thursday, March 17, 2011

Attention all parents [UPDATE]

Att: Non-Asian Parents

Please get your kid to learn an instrument. It doesn't really matter which instrument however it is worth noting guitarists are a dime a dozen, drummers are a luxury, but pianists are a dying breed. Music will always be a mark of Christians gathering as we are marked by joy and thankfulness and emotionally expressing our marvelous salvation through song, and so we will always desire musicians to facilitate this.

If money is an issue, then consider only paying for fortnightly lessons, and take the responsibility for their daily practise yourself. The best thing about weekly music lessons for children isn't the instruction per se, but the kick in the pants it gives them to actually practise.

Then once they've had a few years under their belt in classical training, they will need a bit of jazz training. Pay for an extra tutor for six months who can teach them how to build a chord and get beyond the sheet music. Muso's who need the music/follow the music too closely are the achilles heel of most church bands. We should all aim to be like guitarists, who need nothing but the 6 chords scribbled on the back of an envelope.

The other benefit is music is an easy and obvious way for the youngsters to begin serving in the church, because music relies almost entirely on the theological reflections of others. And if they're really self-conscious, get them up there for the first few months without plugging them in.

Att: Asian parents

Keep up the good work.

[UPDATE]
Some further thoughts:
  • People can be too precious about music (a true statement in general), but especially about the level of musicianship required to serve the body. It is often as if the idea of training younger members to serve applies in every serving capacity in our gatherings except in the band.
  • Asking someone from church who is proficient as a musician to teach your child is no guarantee of quality. Not everyone is a born teacher. Plus, if you're not paying, you might not value it as much, and lose the motivation to practise due to 'getting your money's worth'.
  • No one likes the recorder. No one. It's hardly even a real instrument. The recorder was created to be sold to primary school children so they could chew on the mouthpiece when bored, and then pass it on (complete with molar impression) to other sickly primary school children. The tin whistle is a musical instrument only in Ireland.
  • The saxophone is dead. Its sound immediately dates the music. Con Campbell is the only exception to this rule.
  • Trumpet and violin can add greatly to musical accompaniment, but generally require a longer gestation behind closed doors before they can be released into the world of church bands. Everyone notices the dud note on these instruments. The guy at the mixing desk can't mute an unmiked trumpet.
  • There are guy instruments and girl instruments. If a girl plays a guy instrument (guitar/drums) she is incredibly cool. The opposite however, does not hold true. Don't make your son learn the flute, unless his name is Ron Burgundy.

10 comments:

  1. I definitely feel like the achilles heel of our church band for the very reason you mentioned. In my (piano) playing, I have been trying to work more with chords/improvising which all seems completely foreign since I was entirely classically trained...but at a stage of life where family and school commitments, other church commitments, a couple of days of work and a bunch of other stuff get in the way, I don't always find it easy to get time to sit down and muck around with arrangements as I would like to. So I just have to pray that God will accept my perhaps slightly less musical ability compared with others...
    Sorry, I'm a teeny bit sensitive about this topic. Probably some tiredness talking...

    ReplyDelete
  2. Hah! Well I am trying to learn guitar - dime a dozen and a boys instrument (?) - because nobody wants my girly flute playing (I believe for a while flutes were "banned" at my church). I'm also not so good at improvising on the flute precisely because I didn't do chords or a whole lot of theory, so here's hoping the guitar remedies that.

    ReplyDelete
  3. This is the most sensible stuff said about church music in a long time. Agree esp with the sax, violin and trumpet comments.

    ReplyDelete
  4. @ Karen
    Great to hear you're serving in this way! A lot of the aspects of musicality that I'm saying I appreciate are often just learnt over time, so keep at it!

    I'm not all that musical myself, so I just know what I like the sound of. But my advice to piano players in general (for what its worth) is that it is helpful to remember most sheet music for piano is scored to be full and rich enough on its own if piano is the sole musical accompaniment.

    But in most contemporary services I've been to, the singer/s cover the melody (so the pianists only really need to play all of the melody if a song is new), and the guitarists (or drummer) cover the rhythm.

    But the piano in my mind provides a richness that enhances almost any church song. And the great benefit is that a piano can take the place of the entire band much easier than a sole guitarist can.

    ReplyDelete
  5. @ Ali
    The flute gets a bad wrap! All things in moderation or something, I reckon.

    it's more of a melody instrument anyway, and works great simply playing the melody in the intro and bars between verses, so the ability to improvise is less important on the flute.

    Keep up with the guitar though. It's great fun, more portable than a piano (maybe not compared to the flute though), and lots of people to give you playing advice! One of my favourite things growing up was camping with a heap of families and sitting round the camp fire out in the bush, passing the guitar between the 1/2 dozen of us who dabbled and having a bit of a sing song.

    @ Jessica
    I'm the voice of reason in a world of chaos. Imagine what the world would be like if everyone listened to me. Equally chaotic I would suggest, but I find it's good every now and then to have a rant and think I know better than everyone else. :)

    Speaking of ranting, let me go on some more...

    I really love singing and playing and making music but unfortunately because of its obvious attachment to our emotional core, music is a big, often unnecessary, cause of disagreements between Christians.

    That's why I occasionally rant on here in general terms, because I would rarely if ever say anything about it to the muso's personally. I'm just thankful for their willingness to serve the body.

    If I wanted to seriously change the way a church approached music (if it was angled towards performance rather than accompaniment, or being obviously driven by a faulty theology) then I probably wouldn't take the direct rebuke approach, or even begin widespread grumbling. As music undeniably appeals to our emotional core, musical preference is seen as just that – subjective preference. Any opinion you have is often seen as an expression of your personal taste.

    So the best bet would be to select a music co-ordinator who is godly in their approach to these things, and change the culture through leadership, over time.

    End rant.

    ReplyDelete
  6. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  7. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  8. So how about the bassoon then? (should rob use it at college?)

    ReplyDelete
  9. Absolutely! I should have added the guiding principle behind all this music stuff is that true class always shines through.

    I guess it was behind the Con Campbell comment, but it equally applies to Rob and his bassoon (isn't that also a kind of monkey?)

    Though Rob tends to play bass guitar at college these days. Bit of a waste having him on that, I reckon.

    ReplyDelete
  10. he says this as the number 10,000 lurks shadily through the recesses of his mind...

    ReplyDelete